Gilmore Girls alum Scott Patterson is ready to dive into one of the most hotly debated love triangles in TV history: is he Team Jess or Team Logan?

Scott – who played Lorelai Gilmore the sullen, flannel shirt-loving love interest (Lauren Graham) about the long-running WB series – this time has returned to the Gilmore Girls universe as a fan. As part of his new iHeartRadio podcast, I Am All In, Scott sees Gilmore Girls for the first time and shares his thoughts on some of the show’s many memorable moments.

In a trailer for the podcast, Scott is asked to provide his opinion on whether Rory (Alexis Bledel) should have ended with her Yale friend Logan (The Resident’s) Matt Czuchry) or Luke’s nephew Jess (This Is Us Star Milo Ventimiglia). Unsurprisingly, Scott chose a family.

“Jess,” Scott confirmed when asked which team he was on. “With an exclamation mark.”

This isn’t the first time Scott has confirmed his choice of Rory and Jess who, much to the disappointment of many Gilmore Girls fans, failed during the four-episode Netflix revival titled A Year In the Life reunited.