Because one of the more surprising – and more delightful! – Revelations from the HBO Max meetup was that Schwimmer and Aniston were almost a real Ross-and-Rachel.

“Honestly, I remember saying to David once, ‘It’ll be such a shame when the first time you and I kiss is on national television,'” said Aniston their mutual infatuation with. “Sure enough, the first time we kissed was in this cafe. So we turned all our adoration and love for one another into Ross and Rachel.”

Now tell us: “Oh. My. Gawwwwwwd.”

While this two and a half decade old crush might very well have faded, we can still dream that they’re not quite over it just yet. (Because that, my friend, is what they call closure. Sorry. Had to.) As for the rest of the Friends cast’s love life, here’s what we know, they know, we know.